Assessment for and of Learning
Overview
Assessment is a cornerstone of effective teaching and lies at the heart of Child Development and Pedagogy for Bihar TET. Understanding the distinction between **Assessment for Learning** (formative) and **Assessment of Learning** (summative) is essential because it shapes how teachers support student growth versus how they certify achievement.
This topic appears frequently in CDP questions, often testing candidates on definitions, purposes, timing, and examples of both assessment types. The National Curriculum Framework (NCF) 2005 strongly advocates shifting focus from rote-based summative testing toward continuous, formative assessment that supports learning. Bihar TET expects you to understand not just the "what" but the "why" — how assessment philosophy connects to child-centred education.
Mastering this topic helps you answer questions on Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation (CCE), the role of feedback in learning, and constructivist approaches to pedagogy.
---
Key Concepts
- **Assessment for Learning (AfL)** is formative — it happens *during* the learning process to diagnose gaps, provide feedback, and guide instruction. The goal is improvement, not grading.
- **Assessment of Learning (AoL)** is summative — it happens *after* instruction to measure what students have achieved. The goal is certification or reporting.
- **Formative assessment is low-stakes**: It does not contribute to final grades. Examples include oral questions, observation, peer assessment, and quizzes used for feedback.
- **Summative assessment is high-stakes**: It contributes to promotion, certification, or ranking. Examples include term-end exams, board examinations, and standardized tests.
- **Feedback is central to AfL**: Effective formative assessment gives timely, specific feedback that tells students *what* to improve and *how* to improve.
- **Teacher as facilitator vs evaluator**: In AfL, the teacher diagnoses and scaffolds; in AoL, the teacher judges and certifies.
- **NCF 2005 perspective**: The framework criticises excessive reliance on summative exams and recommends integrating formative practices to reduce fear and promote meaningful learning.
- **Both are necessary**: A balanced assessment system uses formative assessment to improve learning and summative assessment to report outcomes.
---
Formulas / Key Facts
| Aspect | Assessment FOR Learning (Formative) | Assessment OF Learning (Summative) | |--------|-------------------------------------|-------------------------------------| | **Purpose** | To improve learning | To certify/report achievement | | **Timing** | During instruction | After instruction | | **Stakes** | Low-stakes | High-stakes | | **Feedback** | Immediate, descriptive, actionable | Delayed, often only grades | | **Examples** | Observation, quizzes, self-assessment, peer review, classroom discussion | Term exams, board exams, unit tests for grading | | **Focus** | Process of learning | Product/outcome of learning | | **Role of error** | Errors are learning opportunities | Errors reduce scores | | **Student role** | Active participant in own learning | Passive recipient of judgement |
**Must-remember facts:** 1. Formative assessment is also called "Assessment as Learning" when students self-assess. 2. CCE (Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation) combines both formative and summative components. 3. RTE Act 2009 discourages detention up to Class VIII, reducing emphasis on summative failure. 4. Diagnostic assessment is a type of formative assessment used to identify specific learning difficulties. 5. Rubrics, checklists, and anecdotal records are tools of formative assessment.
---
Worked Examples
### Example 1: Identifying Assessment Type **Question:** A teacher asks students to write a paragraph and then discusses common errors with the class, allowing revision. What type of assessment is this?
**Solution:**
- Step 1: Check the purpose — the teacher is identifying errors and allowing correction.
- Step 2: Check timing — this happens during the learning process.
- Step 3: Check stakes — no final grade is assigned; focus is on improvement.
- **Answer:** This is **Assessment for Learning (Formative)** because feedback is given to improve student writing before final evaluation.
---
### Example 2: Distinguishing Purpose **Question:** At the end of Class V, students appear for an annual examination. Results are used to promote students to Class VI. What type of assessment is this?
**Solution:**
- Step 1: Timing — "end of Class V" indicates after instruction.
- Step 2: Purpose — results are used for promotion (certification).
- Step 3: Stakes — high, as it determines grade progression.
- **Answer:** This is **Assessment of Learning (Summative)** because it certifies achievement and determines promotion.
---
### Example 3: Application in CCE **Question:** Under CCE, a teacher maintains a portfolio of each child's drawings throughout the year and grades them at term-end. Which assessment types are involved?
**Solution:**
- Maintaining the portfolio with ongoing feedback = **Formative (AfL)**
- Grading the portfolio at term-end for report card = **Summative (AoL)**
- **Answer:** CCE integrates both formative and summative assessment. The process is formative; the final grading is summative.
---
Common Mistakes
1. **Confusing "continuous" with "formative"**
- *Wrong thinking:* Any test given frequently is formative.
- *Correct fix:* Frequency alone doesn't make assessment formative. If a weekly test is graded and counts toward final marks without feedback for improvement, it is summative in nature.
2. **Thinking formative assessment has no structure**
- *Wrong thinking:* Formative means informal and unplanned.
- *Correct fix:* Formative assessment can be structured (planned quizzes, observation schedules). The key is its purpose — to inform teaching and support learning.
3. **Believing summative assessment is "bad"**
- *Wrong thinking:* NCF says we should abolish summative exams.
- *Correct fix:* NCF criticises over-reliance on high-stakes summative tests, not summative assessment itself. Both types serve necessary functions.
4. **Ignoring student involvement in AfL**
- *Wrong thinking:* Assessment is always done by teachers.
- *Correct fix:* Formative assessment includes self-assessment and peer assessment, making students active participants.
5. **Mixing up diagnostic and summative assessment**
- *Wrong thinking:* Diagnostic tests given before teaching are summative.
- *Correct fix:* Diagnostic assessment is formative — it identifies learning gaps to guide instruction, not to certify achievement.
---
Quick Reference
- **AfL = During learning, for improvement; AoL = After learning, for certification.**
- **Formative feedback is descriptive and actionable; summative feedback is often just a grade.**
- **CCE = Formative (FA) + Summative (SA) components.**
- **Errors in formative assessment → learning opportunities; errors in summative → marks deducted.**
- **NCF 2005 advocates reducing exam stress through greater use of formative assessment.**
- **Self-assessment and peer assessment are forms of Assessment as Learning.**